ABSTRACT
Objective:To explore the effect of dialectical diet on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) syndrome score of cirrhotic ascites patients based on "Gu Ben Kai Qu" theory.Methods:From March 2019 to January 2020, 84 patients with liver cirrhosis and ascites admitted to Shuguang Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai University of TCM were randomly divided into two groups according to the different dialectical types of the subjects, 14 cases in each group. Three non-syndrome differentiation diet groups were given routine nursing care of liver cirrhosis ascites. On the basis of routine nursing, the corresponding medicinal diet was selected according to syndrome differentiation based on "Gu Ben Kai Qu" theory. Patients with spleen and kidney yang deficiency syndrome selected Shenqi lean meat decoction. Patients with Yin deficiency of liver and kidney selected Wolfberry and ophiopogon spareribs decoction. Patients with qi stagnation and blood stasis syndrome selected Danggui Sanqi spareribs decoction. The TCM syndrome score scale for liver disease and the curative effect evaluation of cirrhosis ascites were used to evaluate the effect.Results:Eighty effective cases were included. On the first day of admission, the 14th day and the second week after discharge, the TCM syndrome scores of liver disease were as follows: the group (a1b1) with the spleen and kidney yang deficiency syndrome was 46.38±8.56, 34.20±8.42, 31.40±4.22, respectively. The group (a1b2) with the liver kidney yin deficiency syndrome was 41.50±8.71, 31.35±8.63, 31.12±4.94. The group(a1b3) with the qi stagnation and blood stasis syndrome was 45.92±7.86, 35.17±7.57, 30.83±7.32, respectively. The non-syndrome differentiation diet group (a2b1) with the spleen and kidney yang deficiency syndrome was 46.29±8.38, 39.79±7.65, 36.64±6.83, respectively. The non-syndrome differentiation diet group (a2b2) with the liver and kidney yin deficiency syndrome was 40.50±8.12, 38.10±8.93, 35.38±8.24, respectively. The non-syndrome differentiation diet group (a2b3) with the qi stagnation and blood stasis syndrome was 45.62±7.99, 41.83±7.31, 38.83±7.96, respectively. The comparison of TCM syndrome scores of liver disease at three time points was statistically significant ( χ2 value was 63.998, P<0.05), and the comparison between groups was statistically significant ( χ2 value was 20.993, P<0.05). On the 14th day and the second week after discharge, there were significant differences between the groups with the syndrome differentiation diet and another three groups with non-syndrome differentiation diet ( F values were 3.244, 3.489, all P<0.05). Conclusions:Based on the theory of "strengthening the foundation and opening channels", the syndrome differentiation group can effectively reduce the TCM syndrome score of patients with cirrhosis ascites, improve the symptoms and enhance the curative effect. With the development of time, the score of TCM syndrome in patients with liver disease become lower. On the 14th day of admission, patients with Yin deficiency of liver and kidney given medicated diets had significant effect; patients with spleen kidney yang deficiency syndrome or qi stagnation and blood stasis had significant effect in 2 weeks after discharge; which can effectively improve the clinical symptoms of patients with cirrhosis ascites to worthy of clinical application.
ABSTRACT
Objective To explore the effect of applying syndrome differentiation and medicated diet in patients with liver cirrhosis as cites based on"Gu Ben Kai Qu"theory of TCM. Methods Seventy patients of liver cirrhosis as cites were randomly divided into observation group (35 cases) and control group(35 cases).The control group was cared with care routine of liver cirrhosis as cites,The observation group was based on care routine traditional nursing and implementation of dialectical medicalated meal which based on "Gu Ben Kai Qu" theory of TCM. The two groups of patients were used to assess the efficacy of liver cirrhosis as cites,urine volume,abdominal circumference,weight,TCM syndrome scale of liver disease. Results The urine volume on the 7th day, the 14th day, 2 weeks after discharge,the weight and the abdominal circumference on the 2 weeks after discharge from the patients in the observation group were respectively(1.90±0.52)L,(2.09±0.56)L,(2.02±0.35)L,(59.36±8.19)kg,(89.56±7.24)cm,while they were(1.63±0.36)L,(1.79±0.40)L,(1.82±0.38)L,(63.33±8.21)kg,(93.57±7.56)cm in the control group,the difference between the two groups was statistically significant (F=6.083, 6.484, 5.030, 4.108, 5.144,all P<0.05). The efficacy of liver cirrhosis as cites from the patients in the observation group were cured 40.0%(14/35),improved 42.9%(15/35),not cured 17.1%(6/35),while they were cured 22.9%(8/35),improved 40.0%(14/35),not cured 37.1%(13/35),the difference between the two groups was statistically significant (Z=2.012,P<0.05). The efficacy of TCM Syndromes on liver disease from the patients in the observation group were respectively[significant effect 37.1%(13/35),valid 45.7% (16/35),invalid 17.2%(6/35)],[significant effect 60.0%(21/35),valid 28.6%(10/35),invalid 11.4%(4/35)], while they were respectively [significant effect 20.0%(7/35), valid 42.9%(15/35), invalid 37.1%(13/35)], [significant effect 40.0%(14/35),valid 25.7%(9/35),invalid 34.3%(12/35)],the difference between the two groups was statistically significant(Z=2.065,2.104,all P<0.05). Conclusions Based on"Gu Ben Kai Qu"theory of TCM,the implementation of dialectical diet can effectively improve efficacy of liver cirrhosis as cites, reduction rate of TCM symptoms scale, urine volume,reduce the weight,shrink down the abdominal circumference,worthy of clinical application.